Sheetz Secret Menu [Updated 2025]

If you love Sheetz’s made-to-order food, you’re in for a treat. This hidden menu offers unique items not listed on the regular boards. From wild sandwich mashups to indulgent breakfast bites, these secret options bring extra fun to your Sheetz run.

In this guide, we’ll reveal the Sheetz secret menu items, how to order them, and tips to make your experience unforgettable. Let’s dive in!

What Is the Sheetz Secret Menu?

The Sheetz Secret Menu is a collection of off-menu items you won’t find on the standard touchscreen kiosks. These creations blend classic Sheetz flavors in bold, creative ways. Think of it as a treasure hunt for food lovers! Sheetz, a popular convenience store chain since 1952, is known for its customizable MTO (Made-To-Order) options. The secret menu takes that customization to the next level.

Some items started as test runs in places like State College, PA, while others came from clever customers and staff. Availability varies by location, so it’s smart to ask your local Sheetz crew if they can make these goodies.

Top Sheetz Secret Menu Items

Ready to taste something new? Here are the most popular secret menu items based on fan favorites and recent updates as of March 2025.

1. Mac N’ Cheese Burger

• What It Is: A juicy burger topped with creamy mac n’ cheese, bacon, ketchup, mustard, and American cheese.
• Why You’ll Love It: It’s a comfort food combo that’s messy and delicious.
• How to Order: Ask for a burger with mac n’ cheese added as a topping. Specify your extras like bacon or sauce.
• Price Estimate: Around $6-$8, depending on location.

2. French Toast Stick Mess

• What It Is: Crispy French toast sticks mixed with scrambled eggs, sausage, bacon, and melted cheese.
• Why You’ll Love It: Perfect for breakfast or a late-night craving—sweet and savory in every bite.
• How to Order: Request it under “Pop’s Kitchen” on the kiosk or ask the staff to combine these ingredients.
• Price Estimate: About $7-$9.

3. Meatball Pizza Sandwich

• What It Is: Meatballs, marinara, and provolone stuffed inside a folded cheese pizza.
• Why You’ll Love It: It’s an Italian twist that’s hearty and cheesy.
• How to Order: Look for it in the hot dog section on the kiosk or ask for a custom pizza sandwich with meatball toppings.
• Price Estimate: Roughly $8-$10.

4. Grilled Cheese Spicy Chicken Sandwich

• What It Is: Spicy chicken tucked between two grilled cheese sandwiches, with buffalo sauce, lettuce, tomato, and ranch.
• Why You’ll Love It: Crunchy, cheesy, and spicy all at once.
• How to Order: Order a spicy chicken sandwich and request it between grilled cheese slices instead of a bun.
• Price Estimate: Around $7-$9.

5. Taco Quesadilla

• What It Is: A quesadilla with taco-seasoned beef, pico de gallo, Monterey Jack cheese, and Boom Boom sauce.
• Why You’ll Love It: It’s a fusion of Mexican flavors with a Sheetz twist.
• How to Order: Ask for a quesadilla with taco toppings or check the kiosk for “Pop’s Kitchen” options.
• Price Estimate: About $6-$8.

Check out the full Sheetz menu with prices

How to Order from the Sheetz Secret Menu

How to Order from the Sheetz Secret Menu

Ordering these hidden treats is part of the fun. Here’s how to do it:

1. Use the Touchscreen Kiosk:
   • Start at the main menu.
   • Look for “Pop’s Kitchen” (if available) or hidden icons—like in the “Hot Dogs and Brats” section.
   • Select your item and customize as desired.
2. Ask the Staff:
   • If you don’t see it on the kiosk, politely ask an employee. Say something like, “Can you make a Mac ‘n’ Cheese Burger from the secret menu?” Most staff know these items or can figure it out with the MTO system.
3. Order Online:
   • Use the Sheetz app or website. You might need to build the item manually by picking base components (e.g., burger + mac ‘n’ cheese) since secret menu items aren’t always listed.

Pro Tip: Call ahead or check with your local Sheetz. Not all locations have the full secret menu, especially smaller or older stores.

Why Fans Love the Sheetz Secret Menu

People can’t get enough of these hidden gems. Here’s why:

• Variety: Tired of the same old sub? Secret items mix things up.
• Adventure: Trying something new feels exciting and exclusive.
• Customization: Sheetz’s MTO roots shine through you’re in control.
• Taste: Bold flavors like spicy chicken or mac n’ cheese hit the spot.

Nutrition Facts:

These secret items are indulgent, so they’re not light on calories. Here’s a quick look at some nutrition estimates (vary by customization):

• Mac N’ Cheese Burger: ~900 calories, 50g fat, 2000mg sodium.
• French Toast Stick Mess: ~1000 calories, 60g fat, 1800mg sodium.
• Taco Quesadilla: ~700 calories, 35g fat, 1500mg sodium.

Want lighter options? Ask for no cheese or extra veggies. Check Sheetz’s online nutrition calculator for exact details.

Frequently Asked Question

Is the Secret Menu Available Everywhere?

Not yet. It started as a test in places like Altoona and York, PA. Call your local Sheetz to confirm.

How Much Do Secret Items Cost?

Prices range from $6 to $10, depending on ingredients and location. They’re pricier than basic items but worth it for the experience.

Can I Make My Own Secret Item?

Yes! Sheetz’s MTO system lets you invent combos. Try a burger with mozzarella sticks or a sub with nacho toppings.

Final Thoughts: Sheetz Secret Menu

The Sheetz Secret Menu offers a fun twist on your usual order. From a Mac N’ Cheese Burger to a Taco Quesadilla, these hidden gems bring bold flavors. Next time you’re at Sheetz, try asking about “Pop’s Kitchen” or mix and match toppings to create your own secret dish. Your taste buds will love the upgrade!